Shades of Gray
Last August, Angel Lopez, 30, concluded a visit to his hometown in southern Mexico by flying north to Tijuana. He called a coyote, a person who helps sneak people into the United States. The coyote told Lopez and three other Mexican men when and where to jump the border.
Unlike many illicit border crossers, Lopez didn’t dream of finding employment in the United States. He had a job bussing tables five nights a week at Shogun, an upscale bar, sushi bar and restaurant near the beach in Los Angeles. Lopez didn’t hope to earn enough to help support his family in Oaxaca. He’d been sending money for 12 years.
Lopez and the other men did as the coyote said, slipping through a hole in a temporarily unpatrolled stretch of the international fence. They walked north for a few minutes before officers from the U.S. Customs and Border Protection division of the Department of Homeland Security (formerly the Border Patrol) stopped them.
The CBP booked Lopez, charged him with illegal entry, took his thumbprints and sent him back to Mexico on foot.
Following the advice of another coyote, Lopez slipped through a different hole in the international fence two days later. He and two other men hiked north for a half hour along well-worn trails through the chaparral.
When they reached a road, a white Toyota Corolla picked them up. The driver delivered them to San Diego. Lopez paid him $1,500 cash, nearly what he makes in a month bussing tables.
* * *
“This place is full of fake tits and real assholes,” declared Thomas O’Hanlon on a Wednesday evening. The 41-year-old head waiter of Shogun then stepped to the computer and entered the asshole and his silicone enhanced date’s orders.
Affluent Angelenos throng Shogun seven nights a week. They come for the lounge scene and the eclectic cuisine. The restaurant aims for daily sales of $15,000 but routinely tops $20,000.
Still thriving after 15 years of business, Shogun defies the conventional wisdom governing the fickle Los Angeles restaurant industry.
“Most upscale restaurants in this city go into business with a five-year business plan,” says Shogun manager Rachel Kosta, who previously managed a Beverly Hills trattoria with a track record of success spanning decades. “Without reinvention, even the most successful places often can’t sustain profitability beyond four or five years.”
Patrons and Kosta alike credit Shogun’s success and longevity to many things, including “the consistently good food,” “the attractive bar crowd” and “the professionalism of the wait staff.” Another facet of the restaurant’s success remains largely overlooked, the many falsely documented immigrant employees.
L.A. restaurants hungry to fill busser, cook and dishwasher positions that Americans don’t want welcome the counterfeit social security and green cards that undocumented Mexican and Latin-American aliens often purchase on Alvarado Street near downtown Los Angeles. These false documents frequently serve as passports into jobs as bussers and dishwashers.
“Shogun doesn’t have a policy on who we hire to bus tables or wash dishes,” says Kosta. “It’s just that Americans—white people—don’t apply for these jobs.”
Shogun has employed only one non-Latin-American busser in its 15 years of business. Reg Brown, hired in 1994 at age 19, bussed tables for a year before management promoted him to a daytime bartending position. He then became a lunch waiter and eventually an evening bartender. He has worked at Shogun for 11 years now and has exclusively tended bar at night for the past four years.
A number of Mexicans that Brown once bussed tables with have also advanced at Shogun. A few have become runners, employees who deliver food from the kitchen to the customers. A couple others have become bar backs, employees who stock and clean the bar throughout the evening. Bar backs and runners both earn more money than bussers, but waiters and bartenders earn considerably more.
Night waiters and bartenders at Shogun serve affluent Angelenos an average of 25 to 30 hours per week and earn between $40,000 and $65,000 a year. The restaurant reports the net tip incomes of waiters and bartenders on their W-2s. Creative accounting, usually treating this number as if it were gross tip income, allows most of Shogun’s waiters and bartenders to pay taxes on just over half of their actual incomes. As head waiter, O’Hanlon also receives free health insurance, making the barrage of assholes and fake tits bearable.
Shogun’s Mexican employees may labor under a glass ceiling of sorts, but it doesn’t stem from their immigration status.
“Every employee at Shogun has provided the required documentation,” insists Kosta. “As far as I know, they’re all legally employed.”
Stemming from an insufficient knowledge of English and a lack of precedent as much as from outright racism, advancement limitations faced by Shogun’s Mexican employees seem largely self-imposed.
“None of our Mexican dining room employees have ever expressed an interest in waiting tables,” observes Kosta. She also acknowledges that management has never presented them with the possibility.
When asked whether this has anything to do with their ambiguous legal status, Kosta says that she’s paid to manage a restaurant not to scrutinize employment documentation.
Despite their often nebulous legal status and inferior incomes, Shogun’s immigrant workers tend to take greater pride in their jobs than their American counterparts. Head waiter Thomas O’Hanlon says he appreciates his job but deems himself “just a waiter.” Brown has tended Shogun’s bar for years, but ask him what he really does. He’ll tell you he’s an actor.
By U.S. standards, the workaday existences of Shogun’s immigrant employees may seem tedious. But most of these laborers enjoy the satisfaction of having realized a better life for themselves. To an extent, they live the American dream, and their incomes often support families both north and south of the international fence.
* * *
Unlike Kosta, CBP officers do scrutinize residency documentation. Otherwise, Angel Lopez could have saved hundreds of dollars, avoided much physical and financial risk and shaved two days of travel from his trip to visit his family by flying round-trip between Los Angeles and Oaxaca. Instead, he had to get creative.
Lopez’s brother Martin has a real green card, identity documentation that confirms the permanent resident status of an alien in the United States. This allows him to enter, to exit, to work and to reside in the United States. Because Mexico rarely checks the status of people crossing the international border in a southerly direction, Martin drove his brother from Los Angeles to Mexico at the outset of his trip. From the Tijuana airport, Lopez purchased a round-trip ticket to Oaxaca. Including the services of the coyote, he paid over $2,000 to get from Los Angeles to Oaxaca and back.
At the time of his arrest for illegal entry, Lopez had no criminal record. He now does. If authorities catch him reentering or residing in the United States without proper documentation, Lopez will face a maximum federal prison sentence of seven years. If he’s lucky, the fact that he has proven himself an exemplary employee at Shogun for the past seven years may earn him a more lenient sentence from a sympathetic judge. It may not.
Such stiff penalties do little to deter illegal immigration. A depressed Mexican economy and an ongoing demand for unskilled labor in the United States combine with U.S. immigration laws to create a thriving business for coyotes. But many undocumented immigrants can’t afford their services. The restaurant pays all of its dishwashers, prep cooks and tipped employees California’s legal minimum wage, $6.75 an hour.
“Not a day goes by without at least a handful of hopeful people applying for jobs here,” said Kosta. “The experienced ones who don’t speak English even know to knock on the rear entrance that leads to the kitchen.”
English may be the official language of Shogun’s dining room, but Spanish rules the kitchen. Much like the international fence separating the United States from Mexico, a cultural border seems to lie between the dining room and the busser station, which leads to the restaurant’s kitchen.
A graduate of Venice High School with a sophisticated knowledge of English, Lopez crosses both borders with little concern or difficulty. He laughs at his tale of slinking across the U.S.-Mexican border.
Many in his position, including most of the Mexicans employed at Shogun, don’t find the situation so amusing.
Roberto Jimenez prepares hot appetizers and sandwiches during lunches at Shogun. During dinners, he prepares hot appetizers and salads. At 10:30 p.m. on weekdays and at 11:00 p.m. on weekends, Shogun’s Japanese chefs go home, and the restaurant switches from its regular menu to a condensed, late supper menu. From the time of the switch until the kitchen closes at midnight, Jimenez prepares everything.
He works six days a week, 13 to 14 hours a day. He punches different timecards for his lunch and dinner shifts, so he never earns overtime. He appreciates this system. Since most restaurants avoid paying overtime, Jimenez would otherwise have to find a second job and commute by bike between it and Shogun in order to work as many hours as he does now. He’d also lose the income associated with the time spent commuting.
Shogun’s system denies Jimenez pay of one-and-a-half times his hourly salary for the ninth through the 12th hours he puts in each day. Beyond 12 hours, the law entitles him to double his normal hourly salary.
Jimenez does not know this. He’s never earned overtime, and he doesn’t expect extra pay. He’s happy to work 13 to 14 hours a day for a single employer who realizes and appreciates the long hours he puts into his job. At least Shogun’s management recognizes the cause of his exhaustion at the end of his shift. Kosta usually buys him a beer.
Jimenez cranks out lobster enchiladas and steak salads with truffle dressing that cost customers more than $15 apiece. He earns $9 an hour. For comparison, In-N-Out Burger, a Southern California fast-food chain that exclusively sells hamburgers, fries, sodas and shakes, pays its employees a starting minimum wage of $9 an hour. Unlike headwaiter Thomas O’Hanlon, Shogun doesn’t pay for Jimenez’s health insurance. He can’t afford it, so he goes without. So do his wife and 3-year-old daughter.
Jimenez has worked at Shogun for 11 years. He hasn’t returned to Mexico or seen his parents in 12 years. Jimenez can afford to take a few days off work, but he can’t manage the $1,500 to $3,000 a coyote will charge to sneak him back into the United States. If he takes his undocumented wife, the price will double. So he stays in Los Angeles, continues to work and suppresses tears whenever anyone asks about his parents in Oaxaca. Both in their 70s, Jimenez fears they will die before he sees them again.
Even a death in the family doesn’t ensure a timely reunion for members of Shogun’s undocumented workforce. Jorge Lopez, another falsely documented Oaxacan employed at the restaurant, had a brother in Mexico who died in mid-April. After considering the expense and legal risk of reentering the United States, Jorge decided that he couldn’t afford to attend the funeral.
The financial and emotional burden on falsely documented Mexican immigrants doesn’t begin and end at the U.S.-Mexican border.
Abel Sanchez works alongside two Japanese chefs and two falsely documented Oaxacan assistants at Shogun’s sushi bar. He prepares sushi for one-third of the bar as well as for customers in the main dining room. After nine years on the job, he wields a sashimi knife with the skill of a veteran sushi chef. Many regulars wait longer than necessary to sit at Sanchez’s end of the bar. They often tip generously.
During a typical night, Shogun’s sushi bar brings in between $200 and $400 in tips. The Japanese chefs collect and disperse the money, splitting the majority amongst themselves. They usually give Sanchez between $30 and $40. The Mexican assistants receive about half that much.
Sanchez and the other Mexicans recognize the inequity, but they keep their complaints to themselves. They know that the Japanese make the hiring and firing decisions in the kitchen. The Japanese also understand Spanish. On the rare occasion that the Mexicans do complain, they speak in Zapotec, their native Oaxacan tongue.
The Mexicans know that the Japanese didn’t buy their green cards on Alvarado Street. Based on their culinary training, Shogun sponsors its Japanese chefs with the Department of Homeland Security’s Citizenship and Immigration Services (formerly the Immigration and Naturalization Service), allowing them to live and to work permanently in the United States.
The CIS issues hundreds of thousands of green cards to foreign nationals each year. The service classifies applicants into various categories then ranks them by desirability. This process deems most Mexicans unskilled laborers. Considered the lowest immigration priority, many Hispanics and Latin Americans eschew the daunting legal immigration process in favor of jumping the border and acquiring false documentation.
In 2000, the Immigration and Naturalization Service estimated that 7 million unauthorized immigrants lived in the United States, exactly double the 1990 estimate. Over 68 percent of all unauthorized immigrants in the United States hailed from Mexico, reported the INS, while another 14 percent came from other Central and South American nations.
Nearly a third of the unauthorized immigrants resided in California, according to the INS. These immigrants had little difficulty assimilating. The U.S. Census Bureau determined that over 32 percent of the California’s population in 2000 came from Hispanic or Latino origin.
Ironically, many of Shogun’s Mexican employees, including Lopez, have lived and worked in the United States and at the restaurant far longer than their Japanese counterparts.
* * *
After Lopez successfully crossed the border back into the United States, his brother picked him up in San Diego and delivered him to Venice Beach. Lopez returned to work the following night.
He received a warm welcome from both his fellow Oaxacan and American employees. The Japanese acknowledged neither his absence nor his return.
Last August, Angel Lopez, 30, concluded a visit to his hometown in southern Mexico by flying north to Tijuana. He called a coyote, a person who helps sneak people into the United States. The coyote told Lopez and three other Mexican men when and where to jump the border.
Unlike many illicit border crossers, Lopez didn’t dream of finding employment in the United States. He had a job bussing tables five nights a week at Shogun, an upscale bar, sushi bar and restaurant near the beach in Los Angeles. Lopez didn’t hope to earn enough to help support his family in Oaxaca. He’d been sending money for 12 years.
Lopez and the other men did as the coyote said, slipping through a hole in a temporarily unpatrolled stretch of the international fence. They walked north for a few minutes before officers from the U.S. Customs and Border Protection division of the Department of Homeland Security (formerly the Border Patrol) stopped them.
The CBP booked Lopez, charged him with illegal entry, took his thumbprints and sent him back to Mexico on foot.
Following the advice of another coyote, Lopez slipped through a different hole in the international fence two days later. He and two other men hiked north for a half hour along well-worn trails through the chaparral.
When they reached a road, a white Toyota Corolla picked them up. The driver delivered them to San Diego. Lopez paid him $1,500 cash, nearly what he makes in a month bussing tables.
* * *
“This place is full of fake tits and real assholes,” declared Thomas O’Hanlon on a Wednesday evening. The 41-year-old head waiter of Shogun then stepped to the computer and entered the asshole and his silicone enhanced date’s orders.
Affluent Angelenos throng Shogun seven nights a week. They come for the lounge scene and the eclectic cuisine. The restaurant aims for daily sales of $15,000 but routinely tops $20,000.
Still thriving after 15 years of business, Shogun defies the conventional wisdom governing the fickle Los Angeles restaurant industry.
“Most upscale restaurants in this city go into business with a five-year business plan,” says Shogun manager Rachel Kosta, who previously managed a Beverly Hills trattoria with a track record of success spanning decades. “Without reinvention, even the most successful places often can’t sustain profitability beyond four or five years.”
Patrons and Kosta alike credit Shogun’s success and longevity to many things, including “the consistently good food,” “the attractive bar crowd” and “the professionalism of the wait staff.” Another facet of the restaurant’s success remains largely overlooked, the many falsely documented immigrant employees.
L.A. restaurants hungry to fill busser, cook and dishwasher positions that Americans don’t want welcome the counterfeit social security and green cards that undocumented Mexican and Latin-American aliens often purchase on Alvarado Street near downtown Los Angeles. These false documents frequently serve as passports into jobs as bussers and dishwashers.
“Shogun doesn’t have a policy on who we hire to bus tables or wash dishes,” says Kosta. “It’s just that Americans—white people—don’t apply for these jobs.”
Shogun has employed only one non-Latin-American busser in its 15 years of business. Reg Brown, hired in 1994 at age 19, bussed tables for a year before management promoted him to a daytime bartending position. He then became a lunch waiter and eventually an evening bartender. He has worked at Shogun for 11 years now and has exclusively tended bar at night for the past four years.
A number of Mexicans that Brown once bussed tables with have also advanced at Shogun. A few have become runners, employees who deliver food from the kitchen to the customers. A couple others have become bar backs, employees who stock and clean the bar throughout the evening. Bar backs and runners both earn more money than bussers, but waiters and bartenders earn considerably more.
Night waiters and bartenders at Shogun serve affluent Angelenos an average of 25 to 30 hours per week and earn between $40,000 and $65,000 a year. The restaurant reports the net tip incomes of waiters and bartenders on their W-2s. Creative accounting, usually treating this number as if it were gross tip income, allows most of Shogun’s waiters and bartenders to pay taxes on just over half of their actual incomes. As head waiter, O’Hanlon also receives free health insurance, making the barrage of assholes and fake tits bearable.
Shogun’s Mexican employees may labor under a glass ceiling of sorts, but it doesn’t stem from their immigration status.
“Every employee at Shogun has provided the required documentation,” insists Kosta. “As far as I know, they’re all legally employed.”
Stemming from an insufficient knowledge of English and a lack of precedent as much as from outright racism, advancement limitations faced by Shogun’s Mexican employees seem largely self-imposed.
“None of our Mexican dining room employees have ever expressed an interest in waiting tables,” observes Kosta. She also acknowledges that management has never presented them with the possibility.
When asked whether this has anything to do with their ambiguous legal status, Kosta says that she’s paid to manage a restaurant not to scrutinize employment documentation.
Despite their often nebulous legal status and inferior incomes, Shogun’s immigrant workers tend to take greater pride in their jobs than their American counterparts. Head waiter Thomas O’Hanlon says he appreciates his job but deems himself “just a waiter.” Brown has tended Shogun’s bar for years, but ask him what he really does. He’ll tell you he’s an actor.
By U.S. standards, the workaday existences of Shogun’s immigrant employees may seem tedious. But most of these laborers enjoy the satisfaction of having realized a better life for themselves. To an extent, they live the American dream, and their incomes often support families both north and south of the international fence.
* * *
Unlike Kosta, CBP officers do scrutinize residency documentation. Otherwise, Angel Lopez could have saved hundreds of dollars, avoided much physical and financial risk and shaved two days of travel from his trip to visit his family by flying round-trip between Los Angeles and Oaxaca. Instead, he had to get creative.
Lopez’s brother Martin has a real green card, identity documentation that confirms the permanent resident status of an alien in the United States. This allows him to enter, to exit, to work and to reside in the United States. Because Mexico rarely checks the status of people crossing the international border in a southerly direction, Martin drove his brother from Los Angeles to Mexico at the outset of his trip. From the Tijuana airport, Lopez purchased a round-trip ticket to Oaxaca. Including the services of the coyote, he paid over $2,000 to get from Los Angeles to Oaxaca and back.
At the time of his arrest for illegal entry, Lopez had no criminal record. He now does. If authorities catch him reentering or residing in the United States without proper documentation, Lopez will face a maximum federal prison sentence of seven years. If he’s lucky, the fact that he has proven himself an exemplary employee at Shogun for the past seven years may earn him a more lenient sentence from a sympathetic judge. It may not.
Such stiff penalties do little to deter illegal immigration. A depressed Mexican economy and an ongoing demand for unskilled labor in the United States combine with U.S. immigration laws to create a thriving business for coyotes. But many undocumented immigrants can’t afford their services. The restaurant pays all of its dishwashers, prep cooks and tipped employees California’s legal minimum wage, $6.75 an hour.
“Not a day goes by without at least a handful of hopeful people applying for jobs here,” said Kosta. “The experienced ones who don’t speak English even know to knock on the rear entrance that leads to the kitchen.”
English may be the official language of Shogun’s dining room, but Spanish rules the kitchen. Much like the international fence separating the United States from Mexico, a cultural border seems to lie between the dining room and the busser station, which leads to the restaurant’s kitchen.
A graduate of Venice High School with a sophisticated knowledge of English, Lopez crosses both borders with little concern or difficulty. He laughs at his tale of slinking across the U.S.-Mexican border.
Many in his position, including most of the Mexicans employed at Shogun, don’t find the situation so amusing.
Roberto Jimenez prepares hot appetizers and sandwiches during lunches at Shogun. During dinners, he prepares hot appetizers and salads. At 10:30 p.m. on weekdays and at 11:00 p.m. on weekends, Shogun’s Japanese chefs go home, and the restaurant switches from its regular menu to a condensed, late supper menu. From the time of the switch until the kitchen closes at midnight, Jimenez prepares everything.
He works six days a week, 13 to 14 hours a day. He punches different timecards for his lunch and dinner shifts, so he never earns overtime. He appreciates this system. Since most restaurants avoid paying overtime, Jimenez would otherwise have to find a second job and commute by bike between it and Shogun in order to work as many hours as he does now. He’d also lose the income associated with the time spent commuting.
Shogun’s system denies Jimenez pay of one-and-a-half times his hourly salary for the ninth through the 12th hours he puts in each day. Beyond 12 hours, the law entitles him to double his normal hourly salary.
Jimenez does not know this. He’s never earned overtime, and he doesn’t expect extra pay. He’s happy to work 13 to 14 hours a day for a single employer who realizes and appreciates the long hours he puts into his job. At least Shogun’s management recognizes the cause of his exhaustion at the end of his shift. Kosta usually buys him a beer.
Jimenez cranks out lobster enchiladas and steak salads with truffle dressing that cost customers more than $15 apiece. He earns $9 an hour. For comparison, In-N-Out Burger, a Southern California fast-food chain that exclusively sells hamburgers, fries, sodas and shakes, pays its employees a starting minimum wage of $9 an hour. Unlike headwaiter Thomas O’Hanlon, Shogun doesn’t pay for Jimenez’s health insurance. He can’t afford it, so he goes without. So do his wife and 3-year-old daughter.
Jimenez has worked at Shogun for 11 years. He hasn’t returned to Mexico or seen his parents in 12 years. Jimenez can afford to take a few days off work, but he can’t manage the $1,500 to $3,000 a coyote will charge to sneak him back into the United States. If he takes his undocumented wife, the price will double. So he stays in Los Angeles, continues to work and suppresses tears whenever anyone asks about his parents in Oaxaca. Both in their 70s, Jimenez fears they will die before he sees them again.
Even a death in the family doesn’t ensure a timely reunion for members of Shogun’s undocumented workforce. Jorge Lopez, another falsely documented Oaxacan employed at the restaurant, had a brother in Mexico who died in mid-April. After considering the expense and legal risk of reentering the United States, Jorge decided that he couldn’t afford to attend the funeral.
The financial and emotional burden on falsely documented Mexican immigrants doesn’t begin and end at the U.S.-Mexican border.
Abel Sanchez works alongside two Japanese chefs and two falsely documented Oaxacan assistants at Shogun’s sushi bar. He prepares sushi for one-third of the bar as well as for customers in the main dining room. After nine years on the job, he wields a sashimi knife with the skill of a veteran sushi chef. Many regulars wait longer than necessary to sit at Sanchez’s end of the bar. They often tip generously.
During a typical night, Shogun’s sushi bar brings in between $200 and $400 in tips. The Japanese chefs collect and disperse the money, splitting the majority amongst themselves. They usually give Sanchez between $30 and $40. The Mexican assistants receive about half that much.
Sanchez and the other Mexicans recognize the inequity, but they keep their complaints to themselves. They know that the Japanese make the hiring and firing decisions in the kitchen. The Japanese also understand Spanish. On the rare occasion that the Mexicans do complain, they speak in Zapotec, their native Oaxacan tongue.
The Mexicans know that the Japanese didn’t buy their green cards on Alvarado Street. Based on their culinary training, Shogun sponsors its Japanese chefs with the Department of Homeland Security’s Citizenship and Immigration Services (formerly the Immigration and Naturalization Service), allowing them to live and to work permanently in the United States.
The CIS issues hundreds of thousands of green cards to foreign nationals each year. The service classifies applicants into various categories then ranks them by desirability. This process deems most Mexicans unskilled laborers. Considered the lowest immigration priority, many Hispanics and Latin Americans eschew the daunting legal immigration process in favor of jumping the border and acquiring false documentation.
In 2000, the Immigration and Naturalization Service estimated that 7 million unauthorized immigrants lived in the United States, exactly double the 1990 estimate. Over 68 percent of all unauthorized immigrants in the United States hailed from Mexico, reported the INS, while another 14 percent came from other Central and South American nations.
Nearly a third of the unauthorized immigrants resided in California, according to the INS. These immigrants had little difficulty assimilating. The U.S. Census Bureau determined that over 32 percent of the California’s population in 2000 came from Hispanic or Latino origin.
Ironically, many of Shogun’s Mexican employees, including Lopez, have lived and worked in the United States and at the restaurant far longer than their Japanese counterparts.
* * *
After Lopez successfully crossed the border back into the United States, his brother picked him up in San Diego and delivered him to Venice Beach. Lopez returned to work the following night.
He received a warm welcome from both his fellow Oaxacan and American employees. The Japanese acknowledged neither his absence nor his return.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home